About Us

Are you looking for the right jewelry stores in Indiana to purchase from? There is no shame in being very particular about the jewelry store to buy from; after all, jewelry are important investments, and you do not want to make any mistakes. That means you will want to choose consummate professionals to help you find the right jewelry, and for the right price.

Welcome to Distinctive Diamonds, the premier source for diamonds, bridal and fashion jewelry in Indianapolis. We are proud to offer one of the largest selections of independently certified diamonds in America as well as the most sought-after bridal designer lines in the world. When you compare our selection, quality, service, our warranties and guarantees and, most importantly, our value, we are confident you will choose Distinctive Diamonds for your bridal and fine jewelry purchases. Curious buyers in Indiana who need the expertise of jewelry stores to find the right ring for the occasion can trust our jewelers to help them throughout the decision process.

From the World’s Best Mines to Your Finger…

Distinctive Diamonds is a direct diamond importer, offering hand-picked exquisite diamonds cutters. Our president, Eli Benisty grew up in the diamond industry in Tel Aviv, Israel, surrounded by the diamond cutters and brokers in one of the world’s largest diamond exchange centers. For years, Eli worked as a wholesaler, supplying diamonds to jewelry stores here in the Midwest. Through this experience, he saw an opportunity to eliminate unnecessary markups and sell direct to the consumer. His vision was to provide the highest quality diamonds at significantly better values in a more comfortable, no pressure, no risk shopping environment.

The dream became reality when Eli opened Distinctive Diamonds in 2002, forever changing how people in Indianapolis buy diamonds. Today Distinctive Diamonds is the leading bridal jeweler in Indianapolis with a beautiful 5,500 square foot showroom, tens of thousands of satisfied customers, and a solid reputation for integrity and value. This meticulous process allows Distinctive Diamonds to guarantee the best price in the country on independently graded and certified diamonds. We invite you to compare others and then see the extraordinary value only Distinctive Diamonds can provide!

Competitive Prices for Precious Diamonds and Accessories

Of the various jewelry stores in Indianapolis, we have some of the best prices in the industry for diamonds, thanks to our access to the Rapaport Diamond Report. It is through this constantly updated report that we can trace the pricing of diamonds across stores, allowing us to price accordingly and fairly. Buyers in and around Indianapolis looking for trusted jewelers will appreciate our enthusiasm in proudly sharing such information with them, confirming that we indeed have the best possible prices.